Three Years In, the Audit Exposes a Gap in How Indexation Works
Korea's supply price indexation system took full effect in October 2023 and is now in its third year. At the October 7 audit of the Ministry of SMEs and Startups, lawmakers questioned whether the system has actually taken hold in the market. Minister Lee So-young acknowledged that "its effectiveness is still lacking, and because sanctions are weak, there are cases where it simply doesn't work in practice." She said the ministry would carry out a full review covering the trigger requirements, the level of sanctions, and even automatic application through contracts.
The ministry has asked the fiscal authorities for incentives to encourage voluntary participation, such as tax credits for price increases. According to the minister's answer, there has been no concrete progress yet. Since August, energy costs such as electricity and gas have also been covered by indexation. However, the trigger requirements have not changed, so few contracts are actually being adjusted.
Why Costs Rise but Prices Don't Move: The Current Rules
Under the current Act on the Promotion of Mutually Beneficial Cooperation between Large and Small-Medium Enterprises, a "key raw material" is one that accounts for at least 10% of the supply price, and each material is assessed on its own. Take a part supplied at KRW 120 million that uses 9% steel sheet, 8% resin, and 6% coating, and suppose each of those prices rises 7–8%. The supplier's cost burden has clearly grown, but no single material crosses the 10% threshold, so the contract is not covered.
The indexation obligation does not apply at all in the following cases:
Non-indexation agreements are the weak point, because a contractor with more bargaining power can effectively force one on a supplier. Forcing such an agreement or breaching an indexation clause can lead to fines, penalty points, and public disclosure, but many in the field consider these sanctions too weak to deter. Check the Act and its Enforcement Decree for the exact penalty standards.
The October 28 Bill: Up to Three Materials Combined at 20%
A bill to amend the Act was introduced on October 28. According to press reports, it would bring a contract under indexation if the combined share of up to three raw materials is 20% or more, even when each one is below 10%. In the example above, steel, resin, and coating together make up 23%, so the contract would qualify.
The bill has only been introduced. It may be revised during standing committee review, and whether it passes, and when it would take effect, is still undecided. Another thing to watch is whether the "automatic contractual application" and tougher sanctions the minister mentioned make it into a government bill.
What Suppliers Should Do Now (1): Revisit Your Cost Structure
What Suppliers Should Do Now (2): Update Contracts and Agreements
Support Channels and Consulting
Companies that receive the indexation logo and those recognized as outstanding participants can receive government awards and bonus points in various support programs. The Ministry of SMEs and Startups and the Korea Foundation for Cooperation of Large & Small Business, Rural Affairs offer advice on drafting agreements and handling disputes.
KITIM provides product-level cost analysis, reviews of indexation clauses and non-indexation agreements, and mutual-cooperation diagnostic consulting. Updating your cost structure and contracts now, while the amendment is under discussion, puts you in a stronger negotiating position. To find out whether your products could qualify, please request a consultation through KITIM's contact page.
